dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes

When I was a kid, Halloween was my absolute favorite holiday.

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

I mean, I’ve always loved Thanksgiving too, for the food of course, but as a young kid Halloween was the freakin’ best. Turkey and pumpkin pie are great and all but costumes and candy, and running around at night like a little lunatic with fake vampire teeth? Grandma’s cornbread dressing couldn’t hold a candle…

I’ve had countless costumes over the years, but I’ll never forget an especially uncomfortable year dressed as Frankenstein with tons of sticky green makeup and itchy stick-on eyebrows and neck bolts. After that, the simpler and more elegant Dracula was definitely my go to.
Each year I’d get a new costume complete with fangs, cape, and gold medallion, and as a young gay boy I already had all the crisp white button downs and black dress pants that were required but not included with the costume.  (No jeans and T-shirt for this little sissy boy!)
I think it really was the dressed up, fancy man aspect of Dracula that appealed to me most year after year, and it wasn’t until I found my grandma’s old wig in her bathroom closet that the appeal started to wear off…

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

These days I usually spend most of the month of October thinking up all sorts of witty, hysterical costumes that I could wear, but never do. The last time I dressed up was for work, about 4 years ago. I’d just started working at Whisk slinging fancy kitchen gear, and we all came up with this hilarious plan to come to work dressed as a Food Network star.
Group costumes are the best! What could go wrong?!?!

A few days later I show up to work in full Ina Garten regalia, and oops! Everyone either forgot or didn’t have time to get their costumes together.  One person, who usually works from home, loved the idea and actually did come in for an hour or two dressed as Alton Brown (essentially dressed as an older, nerdier version of himself) to take pictures, but everyone else either didn’t dress up or threw something else together at the last minute.
As I stood there working my full shift in an oversized navy blouse, huge clip on pearl earrings, lipstick, and an itchy bob wig; I vowed never again to be duped by allure of an amazing group costume idea.

I haven’t dressed up since.
Womp Womp.

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

Even though I’m too old for trick-or-treating and haven’t put on a costume in years, I really do still have a special place in my heart for Halloween.

I like to imagine that some day in the future I’ll be the type of adult who’s famous among his circle of friends for hosting amazing costume parties that are talked about for years to come. Basically I dream of one day throwing Halloween parties just like the ones on Roseanne, complete with decorations so elaborate and costumes so perfectly spot-on that everyone I know will try, and fail, to one-up me year after year.
By the way, am I the only one who’s ever wondered how the lower middle class Connor family, who always seemed to have trouble paying their bills on time, came up with all the money for their costumes and decorations?
I guess it doesn’t matter, but, like, that stuff ain’t cheap!

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

With all my dreams of Halloween entertaining one-upmanship, the minute I saw this adorable haunted skull cakelet pan, I knew that I HAD to have it.

You all know I love Nordic Ware. I’ve told you more than once twice three times (a lady), but after finally having a chance to use this pan you’ll have to excuse me as I wax poetic once again.

Nordic Ware has been making exceptional cookware and bakeware right here in the US for 70 years now, and even after all this time they’re still a family owned company. The bundt pan is by far their most famous and most popular product, but they also specialize in all sorts of elaborate and festively shaped baking pans. No one can compare to their quality and selection, and ALL of their pans are sturdy, heavy duty, ultra-non-stick, and unbelievably durable.
I should know! I put their pans through the ringer!

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

There is so much detail in these little skulls that I was worried it wouldn’t read once the cakes were baked, or that I’d have problems getting the cakes out cleanly from all the intricate details face and teeth. At this point I should have known that I had no need to worry. These little cakes released like a dream and all that detail came across with amazing definition in the finished cakes.

There’s actually so much detail in these little cakes, that even though I tried decorating them in several ways, I found that my favorite cakes were the simplest, with just a double coat of thin sugary glaze. Of course you can decorate them however you choose, but I really think the simpler, the better. In fact, as much as I love the creepy look of the bright red chocolate candy eyes, I worry that even they take away from the scary perfection of the little cakes as they were straight out of the pan.

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

The recipe below, simply adapted from my favorite chocolate bundt cake recipe, makes 12 mini skulls, or 2 pans worth. If you only have 1 pan, make sure you wash the pan really well between batches. I also recommend that you dry it well and throw it in the fridge or freezer for a few minutes before reapplying the butter and cocoa. Otherwise the pan will be warm from being washed and the butter will melt and make a mess when you try to dust it with cocoa.
If you don’t have this pan at all, you can get it here, or you can just make this recipe in one 10 cup bundt pan. It won’t be as scary to look at, but it’ll certainly taste just as chocolatey and delicious!

By the way, if you’ve never tried this trick before, using cocoa powder works just as well as flour to prevent the cakes from sticking to the pan, but helps the cakes look extra dark and chocolatey, rather than the dusty uneven look flour sometimes gives to the outside of chocolate cakes.

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

The flavor of these little cakes is deep dark chocolate perfect with a super tender and moist crumb. Thanks to that simple powdered sugar glaze, these little cakes almost taste like a reeeeeally good moist chocolate doughnut.

The Oreos, complete with cream (don’t use boxed crumbs!), add a really nice touch, especially if you leave some in nice big chunks so they don’t melt and disappear into the batter. Essentially you just want to put them in a plastic bag and crush ’em up with your hands or whack at them with a rolling-pin until there are no whole cookies left, but you still have lots of bigger pieces.

Now tell me, what kid (or adult) could resist a super moist chocolate cake filled with oreo cookie crumbs? Especially one in the shape of a cute-yet-terrifying little skull???

dark chocolate & oreo mini skull cakes | Brooklyn Homemaker

Dark Chocolate & Oreo Mini Skull Cakes

adapted from Joy the Baker

For the Cake:
1 1/4 cups strong hot coffee
3/4 cup Dutch process cocoa powder (I used “Double Dutch Cocoa“) plus extra for pan
2 1/2 cups sugar
1 1/4 teaspoons kosher salt
2 teaspoons baking soda
2 whole eggs
1 egg yolk
1 1/4 cups buttermilk
1 cup peanut oil or any neutral vegetable oil
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
3 cups all-purpose flour
2 cups (about 1 package) roughly crushed oreos (NOT oreo cookie crumbs, you want the cream too)

For the Glaze:
2 cups powdered sugar
1/4 cup milk
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

For decorating (all optional):
Red M&Ms
Sanding or decorating sugar (black, red, or silver)
white mini nonpareils
More crushed Oreos

Place an oven rack in the center of the oven and preheat to 350 degrees F.
Brush a skull cakelet pan (* see note) with softened butter, and dust with cocoa powder, tapping out any excess.

Whisk coffee and cocoa together in a bowl together until free of lumps and set aside.
In the bowl of a stand mixer with a whisk attachment, mix together sugar, salt, baking soda, eggs and egg yolk on low for just one minute. Add the buttermilk, oil and vanilla extract and mix on low again for another minute.
Add the flour and mix on medium speed for 2 minutes more. Add the cocoa mixture and mix on medium speed for 3 minutes. Finally, stir in the roughly crushed Oreos just until evenly distributed throughout. The batter will seem quite loose and liquid, it’s supposed to, don’t worry.
Pour half of the batter into the prepared cake pan, filling each cavity about 3/4 of the way up. This recipe makes two pans worth of batter. If you have two pans, you can bake them both at once, or once the first batch is out of the pan you can wash, dry, and cool the pan in the fridge before reapplying butter and cocoa and baking the remaining batter.
Bake for 20-30, or until a cake tester or toothpick inserted in the cake comes out clean.

Let the cake cool for at least 15 minutes before inverting onto a cooling rack.

To make the glaze:
Whisk the powdered sugar, milk, and vanilla together in a medium bowl until smooth and free of lumps.

To glaze and decorate:
After some trial and error I found that the easiest way to glaze the cakelets was to pick up them up by the base and dip them into the glaze like a doughnut. Remove from the glaze, let drip dry, and turn over to dry on a cooling rack. I actually liked the look of the glaze best when the cakes were glazed twice. If you want to double glaze, wait for the first coat to dry five minutes or so before dipping again.
If you’d like to decorate with sanding sugar, crushed Oreos, or mini nonpareils, sprinkle them over the cakes before your final coat of glaze has dried. If desired, add red chocolate candies in the eye sockets.

*Note: If you don’t have a skull cakelet pan this recipe makes 1 (less spooky but equally delicious) bundt cake in a 10 cup bundt pan. A bundt will need to bake for about 55 to 65 minutes .



  1. Very cool. I’ve never celebrated Halloween, it’s only starting to become a ‘thing’ here in Australia and I’m pretty desperate to actually participate. The idea of dressing up, eating deliciously disgusting food, collecting candy, I mean… what’s not to like?! When I do actually organise a Halloween party (my first as an adult sounds kinda weird but it’s never too late, right?!) I will definitely make these creepy skull cakes!

    Oh, and thumbs down to your colleagues for lack of participation in the Food Network costuming. Seriously poor form! I reckon you stole the show ;)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s definitely never too late to have a halloween party! As an adult your costume options are so much wider because adults actually get subtlety, irony, and wit in a way kids never do! ;)
      And I’m seriously scarred for life when it comes to the group costume department, but I definitely stole the show. In fact, I WAS the show! hahahaaha!


  2. Wow, these skulls are some of the creepiest Halloween treats I’ve seen all year – and I mean that as a compliment, obviously! I love Halloween as well, but I haven’t dressed up for it in years…and I can certainly understand why you haven’t after the group costume debacle. Oh and thanks for the tip about using cocoa powder in place of flour to dust the pan!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. They look sooo yummy in a scary sort of way. I have to say Tux, as your Mom, the best costume you wore for Halloween in my opinion was Richard Simmons, when you first moved to New York. You totally killed it in that! I will never forget the Halloween parties at our house as you were growing up. The feast you put on for your friends even as a young teenager, WOW. Although I was usually trying to keep away to give you your privacy, I wished I had a friend that threw parties like you did when I was a kid! You have been a great host all your life. You did make an awesome Dracula and pretty freaky as well. I think your Ina Garten was spot on too! You should share some of those pics! I will be thinking of you lots while I scare my trick or treaters this year.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. These look amazing! I would love to try them this Halloween at my annual “Spooky Dinner Party.” Due to health reasons I cannot have coffee. Could you recommend a substitute? Thank you very much!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Ruby! Thank you for your comment. The coffee just adds a little bit of extra depth to the cocoa, but leaving it out won’t have a huge affect on the flavor of the cake. I’d suggest just using very hot water in place of the coffee.

      Your dinner party sounds like so much fun! I hope you and all your guests love these cakes!


  5. I realized today reading through this that my favorite posts of yours typically include the phrase “as a young gay boy…” somewhere in the text lol

    I’ve always been a huge fan of Halloween too, even if I’m not necessarily partaking in any of the festivities. My go-to costume in college was classic Amy Winehouse, with a giant black wig that I teased into a beehive myself, and thick black eyeliner that took 3 days to disappear fully. I haven’t dressed up in years, but I’ve always dreamed of going full “Lord of the Rings” and doing my best sexy elfish Liv Tyler, but for some reason I can’t get the hubs on board with embracing his inner Aragorn (it’s really not an unreasonable request, idk what his problem is).

    Anyhow, I love these so much! Your cake creations are SO incredible! How do you get the cakes out of the pan so perfectly? I’ve always wondered.

    And don’t worry, someday when we’re neighbors in the Hudson Valley, we can co-host a magnificent Halloween party that puts Roseanne to shame! Except if you’re Ina idk who I’d be. Maybe her bff Barbara? Or the shopkeep where she gets Jeffrey’s brownies? Or, we could go full Martha vs Ina and I could be Martha AFTER Ina murders her with a Le Creuset pan…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Omg zombie Ina and Martha!!! Now THAT is a group costume I can get into!!! Or maybe like Ina and Martha meets “Death Becomes Her”…
      PS my husband is a total Halloween wet blanket too, and if he were any fun I’d probably still be dressing up every year!

      Liked by 1 person

  6. I’m making these tonight using none other than the haunted skull cakelet pan! I had a question – I just purchased the Nordic Ware tombstone cakelet pan. I attempted to make them using a basic white cake recipe and food coloring to make it a gray-ish hue. The cakes did not turn out well – the amazing details of the pan weren’t as detailed as I expected. Any cake recipe suggestions or alterations I can make for a better result? Thank you!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Colleen!
      I usually like to brush softened butter into the pan with a pastry brush to be sure I get every nook and cranny- and then use either flour or cocoa powder to lightly coat the pan.
      I also suggest tapping the pan on the counter to remove any air bubbles from the batter.
      I think a loose/wet batter shows detail a little better than a thick or stiff batter, and the recipe above is quite a loose batter so they came out really nicely for me.
      I hope that helps!


  7. These look amazing!! Also this might be a silly question, but where did you get the marble board that the cakes are displayed on?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.